Vortex dynamics in two-dimensional superfluids

Credit: Dr. Chris Baker, UQ.

Superfluidity is a rich and unusual phenomenon that exhibits macroscopic quantum behaviour. Superfluids have zero viscosity, which means they can flow without loss of kinetic energy. This has very interesting and exiciting implications to future quantum technologies where this dissipationless property of superfluidity could be exploited to, for example, build very low-energy electronic transistors.

However, superfluids can contain quantum vortices – tiny whirlpools that spin around and interact with one another (see the header figure). These vortices can be closely related to the emergence of dissipation in a superfluid. As such, we must study their dynamics to understand how we can predict their behaviour and even, perhaps, control it.

To study these vortices, we can simulate their dynamics on a computer. Our starting point is the superfluid wave function, $\Psi(\mathbf{r},t)$, which describes the superfluid as a classic field. In the limit where the interactions between the superfluid atoms are weak, the dynamics follow the Gross-Pitaevskii equation

$$i\hbar\frac{\partial\Psi(\mathbf{r},t)}{\partial t} = \left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\nabla^2+V(\mathbf{r})+g|\Psi(\mathbf{r},t)|^2\right]\Psi(\mathbf{r},t).$$

Here, $V(\mathbf{r})$ is the trapping potential of the superfluid, and $g$ describes the interactions between the superfluid atoms. By numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equation, we can either directly simulate an experiment to confirm their observations, or gain further information about physics that cannot be directly acccessed in an experiment.

Thin-film superfluid helium

For instance, in one project we worked closely with the Queensland Quantum Optics Lab to study the dynamics of vortices in thin-film superfluid helium. This experiment uses superfluids to perform optomechanical experiments to work towards building ultra-precise quantum sensors.

In their experiment, vortices were present within the superfluid (see schematic below) which led to some unexplained oberservations. Vortices in thin-film superfluid helium cannot be directly imaged, so we simulated their dynamics to gain insight into the experiment and understand their observations. As the Gross-Pitaevskii equation fails for superfluid helium, we used an approximate method called the point vortex model to simulate the vortex dynamics.

Our collaboration led to the first observation of coherent vortex dynamics in a strongly-interacting superfluid in quasi-two-dimensions. Our results can be found summarised here.

Anomalous hydrodynamics

From the superfluid helium experiments, we began to observe some interesting properties about the dynamics of chiral vortex clusters (collections of same-sign vortices). We found that in a finite temperature superfluid, all distributions of chiral vortex clusters expanded to form a Rankine vortex. A Rankine vortex can be thought of as a ‘super vortex’ made up of many vortices that are equally distributed (i.e., a Rankine vortex has a constant vortex density).

We use a new theory that describes collections of vortices within the superfluid as a fluid in its own right. That is, the collection of vortices is thought of as a separate fluid and is goverened by its own Euler equation. In this Euler equation, however, there are additional terms that describe the quantum nature of the vortices giving rise to the name anomalous hydrodynamics.

We found that this theory predicts the emergence of the Rankine vortex due to these anomalous terms. An analytical solution was found, which also described the Rankine vortex was a universal attractor solution. Whilst in classical fluids Rankine vortices are forbidden due to viscosity, they can be supported in superfluids.

Numerically simulating the dynamics of vortices within the point vortex model supported these results, as well as demonstrating further interesting physics such as scaling in the disorder decay and fractured lattice structure exhibiting short and long range correlations.

We found excellent agreement with an experiment observing the expansion of chiral vortex clusters. The UQ BEC lab created a vortex cluster in a Rubidium-87 Bose-Einstein condensate and observed its dynamics over a few seconds. The results demonstrated some key signatures of the anomalous hydrodynamic theory. A sample expansion of the vortex cluster in each of the three regimes can be seen below.

Our work can be found in this paper, appearing in Physical Review Research.

Dynamics of vortex pinning

The final topic we studied was the interaction between single vortices and defects within a superfluid. Vortex pinning is widespread in many systems, ranging from atomic Bose-Einstein condensates, superfluid helium, exciton-polariton condensates, neutron stars, and superconductors. Whilst very well studied in superconductors, there is less understanding of its physical processes in superfluids.

We decided to study the very simple case of a scattering problem between a single quantised vortex and a pinning defect within a superfluid. A schematic for the system can be found below, where the black lines represent sample trajectories of the vortex around the pinning potential.

In our work, we have developed an analytic approximation to study the conservative motion of vortices around the pinning potential. Our model predicts the trajectories, the stationary dynamics of the vortex within the pinning potential, as well as the unpinning of the vortex from the pinning potential.

However, to study the pinning of a vortex, one needs to numerically simulate the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. Sampling the parameter space, we find that there are two distinct regimes of vortex pinning, each marked by a characteristic emission of sound energy. Through these simulations, we have learnt that vortices are generated within the pinning potential to assist with pinning, as well as to stabilise vortices within the pinning potential which makes it more difficult to pull vortices from the pinning potential. Our results may have interesting implications for understanding neutron star dynamincs, as well as aiding in the development of low-energy superfluid transistors.

A detailed study of the work described here can be found in my Master’s thesis.

Oliver Stockdale
Oliver Stockdale
PhD student in Physics

My research interests include ultracold quantum gases, entanglement detection, entropic uncertainty relations, and superfluidity